- Amber Tamblyn Tibby
- America Ferrera Carmen
- Blake Lively Bridget
- Alexis Bledel Lena
- Bradley Whitford Al
- Nancy Travis Lydia Rodman
- Rachel Ticotin Madre de Carmen
- Jenna Boyd Bailey
- Mike Vogel Eric
- Leonardo Nam Brian McBrian
- George Touliatos Papou
- Brenda James Barbara the Tailor
- Kendall Cross Madre de Bridget