- Aaron Eckhart Bill
- Jessica Alba Lucy
- Elizabeth Banks Jess
- Logan Lerman El Estudiante
- Holmes Osborne Mr Jacoby
- Timothy Olyphant Chip Johnson
- Reed Diamond Paul
- Todd Louiso John Jr.
- Kristen Wiig Jane Whitman
- Marisa Coughlan Laura
- Jason Sudeikis Jim Whittman
- Gabriel Basso