- Ryan Reynolds Monty
- Anna Faris Serena
- Justin Long Dean
- David Koechner Dan
- John Francis Daley Mitch
- Emmanuelle Chriqui Tyla
- Andy Milonakis Nick
- Alanna Ubach Naomi
- Jordan Ladd Danielle
- Chi McBride Bishop
- Luis Guzmán Raddimus
- Dane Cook Floyd
- Max Kasch T-Dog