- Jared Padalecki Clay
- Danielle Panabaker Jenna
- Aaron Yoo Chewie
- Amanda Righetti Whitney
- Travis Van Winkle Trent
- Derek Mears Jason Voorhees
- Arlen Escarpeta Lawrence
- Julianna Guill Bree
- Willa Ford Chelsea
- Jonathan Sadowski Wade
- Ben Feldman Richie
- Ryan Hansen Nolan