- Jennifer Garner Cindy Green
- Joel Edgerton Jim Green
- Cameron 'CJ' Adams Timothy Green
- Odeya Rush Joni Jerome
- Rosemarie DeWitt Brenda Best
- M. Emmet Walsh Tío Bub
- Lin-Manuel Miranda Reggie Marks
- Dianne Wiest Bernice Crudstaff
- Ron Livingston Franklin Crudstaff
- Lois Smith Tía Mel
- Common Entrenador Cal
- Michael Arden Doug Wert
- Steve Coulter Charlie Frohn
- Karan Kendrick