- Reese Witherspoon Pam Hobbs
- Colin Firth Ron Lax
- Mireille Enos Vicki Hutcherson
- Stephen Moyer John Fogelman
- Kevin Durand John Mark Byers
- James Hamrick Damien Echols
- Bruce Greenwood Juez David Burnett
- Alessandro Nivola Terry Hobbs
- Amy Ryan Margaret Lax
- Elias Koteas Jerry Driver
- Collette Wolfe Glori Shettles
- Martin Henderson Brent Davis
- Brian Howe Detective McDonough
- Dane DeHaan
- Matt Letscher Paul Ford