- Jason Sudeikis Kurt Buckman
- Charlie Day Dale Arbus
- Jason Bateman Nick Hendricks
- Jennifer Aniston Julia Harris
- Jamie Foxx Dean "MF" Jones
- Chris Pine Rex Hanson
- Christoph Waltz Bert Hanson
- Kevin Spacey Dave Harken
- Jonathan Banks Detective Hatcher
- Lindsay Sloane Stacy Arbus
- Keegan-Michael Key Mike
- Kelly Stables Rachel
- Lidia Porto Candy
- Suzy Nakamura Kim
- Rob Huebel Pinkberry Executive
- Sam Richardson Productor