- Jessica Chastain Tammy Faye Bakker
- Andrew Garfield Jim Bakker
- Cherry Jones Rachel
- Mark Wystrach Gary Paxton
- Gabriel Olds Pat Robertson
- Jay Huguley Jimmy Swaggart
- Vincent D'Onofrio Jerry Falwell
- Sam Jaeger Roe Messner
- Kevin J. O'Connor PTL Crew Supervisor